This article will focus on a few of the best dog training collar and shock collars for dogs products available on the market. I have included waterproof collars, smart collars, and budget choices. You should find exactly what you need.
Best Dog Training Collars for 2023 (Top 5) – Reviews & Buying Guide
- 1 Dog Training Collars Comparison Table
- 2 Dog Training Collar 2023 Reviews
- 3 Dog Training Collar Buying Guide
- 4 Frequently Asked Questions about Training Collars for Dogs
Dog Training Collars Comparison Table
|Top dog training collar||DOG CARE Rechargeable Dog Shock Collar||
|Best non-shocking collar||Educator E-Collar||
|Most affordable training collar for two dogs||Petrainer Shock Collar for Dogs||
|Best waterproof dog training collar||SportDOG 425||
|Top long distance training collar||Dogtra Edge Dog Training Collar||
Dog Training Collar 2023 Reviews
Here’s our picks for the Best Dog Training Collars and Dog Shock Collar.
Best Dog Shock Collar: DOG CARE
The DOG CARE collar works great for training all kinds of dogs. You can train puppies and even adult dogs with this device. In fact, you can control 9 species with the remote, so you can train your entire litter at the same time.
This collar also has a security keypad, so you don’t have to worry about accidentally shocking, vibrating, or beeping your dog. The keypad makes this very child friendly, too. As for the level of shock, you have 99 different levels of shock to choose from. I think you can find a level that works.
Speaking of that, the size is highly adjustable. You can fit it on all but the smallest and biggest dogs. I’d say 15 pounds is the minimum size and 100 pounds is the maximum size dog that can use this collar.
- You can use this remote with 9 different collars, so you can train an entire litter at once.
- Shock, vibration, and beep available. This makes it perfect for dogs of all ages and pain tolerances.
- A very long range of around 1000 feet.
- It’s a smart collar that can be used to prevent your dog from barking.
Best Non-Shocking Dog Collar: Educator E-Collar
First, the Educator uses ‘blunt’ stimulation to train the dog. Basically, it’s some pressure applied via one of the two contact points. It works great, and it doesn’t stress out your dog. I’d say that’s a win.
This product is also available in 2 collars, so you can easily synchronize your dog training. Of course, that’s optional. If you only have one dog, then you can purchase a single collar.
I really like the range on this device. It’s about ½ mile, which makes it great for training dogs to not run too far. I could see it getting plenty of use on a farm or other large property.
The deterrent is also highly adjustable. You can adjust it from 1 to 100 one level at a time. And even add an extra boost level (60 levels) for an extra stubborn dog. Remember, it has two contacts, which makes it extra easy to personalize to your dog.
- Very comfortable for your dog.
- The battery is rechargeable and only takes 2 hours to fully charge.
- Does not use electric shock for compliance.
Most Affordable E-Collar for Two Dogs: Petrainer Collar
It has an electric shock, audio, and vibration settings that make it extremely flexible for all types of training. It has the usual 0-100 adjustability, so you can use it with almost any dog. It even has a range of 1000 feet, so you can let your dog wander while conducting the training.
I like the LCD display. It even has a backlight that makes it readable at night. Even better, this device is actually waterproof. Now, I wouldn’t use it for serious water training, but it won’t get damaged if your dog runs through a puddle.
Most interestingly is that the collar and remote have separate chargers, so you can charge them at the same time. You don’t have to charge them at one at a time. It might sound small and inconsequential, but it really does make everything much more convenient.
I also like that this product has a warranty. I know many people are skeptical of dog electric collars at this price. However, the one year warranty should put you at ease.
- It’s waterproof, which is a little surprising at this price.
- 1000 foot range.
- The warranty is for one year.
- Very, very affordable.
Best Waterproof Dog Training Collar: SportDOG 425
SportDOG has a great reputation in the dog training device industry. And the SportDOG 425 is no different. This specific product is marketed more towards hunters training dogs to retrieve ducks. The 1500’ range, 3 collar compatibility, and waterproof design really do make this perfect for hunters. It’s also great for average dog owners, but it’s just perfect for hunters. Keep in mind that the SportDOG 425 only comes with one collar and remote. You can purchase extra ones on Amazon, though.
Anyway, the 425 has a one-time and continuous shock option. Again, this works great for hunters training their dogs to retrieve ducks or follow scents. Even better is that this device is fully waterproof up to 25 feet. And I don’t think your dog is diving down 25 feet, so it should be perfect.
I like the lithium-ion batteries that only take two hours to charge and last for up to 70 hours. The battery is indicator is also nice. You don’t have to worry about it randomly dying on you.
As for the price, it’s really not bad for all the features that you get. It’s only marginally more expensive than my top pick. With that said, I still only recommend this for hunters or other people that have to train their dogs in the water.
- Electric stimulation is adjustable to 7 different levels.
- Very adjustable – the minimum size dog the receiver will fit is 7 pounds. There is no maximum.
- The collar is highly adjustable. Neck sizes from 4.75 inches to 22.5 inches will comfortably fit in it.
Top Long Distance Training Collar: Dogtra Edge
Dogtra Edge shock collar has a very impressive working range of nearly a mile. You can quite literally train your dog from a mile away – that’s impressive. This device has lots of features that you will love.
First, it’s activated via remote, so you don’t have to touch your dog during training. It has three types of stimulation that include one-time, constant, and vibrate. And it is 100% waterproof, so you can use it while it’s raining. Remember, your dog still has to go outside to relieve itself.
It has the most adjustability of any collar on the list with 127 levels of electric available. You can use it on the most sensitive dog or the most stubborn dog. It’s also compatible with multiple collars, so you can use it to train your dogs simultaneously.
The product gets overall good reviews. But the range is what really sets it apart from other dog training devices. I highly recommend this if you want to do some long-distance dog training.
- 1-mile range.
- 3 different operating modes: one-time, constant, and vibrate.
- It works best with dogs over 34 pounds.
Dog Training Collar Buying Guide
There are a few features that you should look for in a dog e-collar. Here are some of the most important ones.
The different modes available are very important when choosing your training supply. Personally, I recommend shock collars since they tend to work the best. But you don’t have to use them these days.
Many collars will vibrate or even beep. In my experience, this isn’t nearly as effective for training a dog. However, some owners don’t enjoy shocking their dogs.
The list includes products that have all different types of modes available for use.
Range, in my opinion, isn’t really that important of a feature for most people. You just aren’t training your dog from far enough of a distance for it to be a problem. However, if the distance is a concern (ex. Hunting dogs), then you should look at some of the long-range options that I have listed. Those long-range options have a range of up to a mile, which does work well for hunting dogs or farm dogs.
However, the average range of a dog training collar is about 1000 feet, and that should be enough for all but the most specialized of uses.
A fence option is a setting that allows you to set up a fenced zone for your dog. This works especially well for people that want to use a shock collar as a form of an electric fence. In fact, it’s much easier than setting up your own electric fence.
You can purchase smart collars that automatically give your dog a little shock when they bark. These are great for when you’re not at your home or apartment. Or if you don’t want to constantly monitor your dog.
Frequently Asked Questions about Training Collars for Dogs
Here are some of the most frequently asked questions about dog shock collars.
- What is a dog training collar?
For our purposes, it is a collar that uses some type of alert to classically condition your dog. The alert is typically an electric shock administered by you. Some products emit a sound and others vibrate. In my experience, e-collars that emit a tiny amount of discomfort tend to work best on stubborn dogs. Shy dogs can often be trained with just a sound or vibration.
- Will a training collar hurt my dog?
No. It will make your dog uncomfortable, but it will not hurt your dog. You can try the collar on yourself – it’s just about as bad as a normal shock from your carpet. Plus, dogs can handle a little pain. Just look at the way they play with each other.
- Does a vibrating training collar work?
It depends on the dog. A dog that frightens easily (ex. chihuahuas) will probably respond quite well to a vibrating training. They won’t work well with stubborn dogs. And they also don’t work well at preventing dogs from eating food. They just don’t make the dog uncomfortable enough.
- What is the maximum amount of time my dog can wear a bark training collar?
You shouldn’t leave a bark collar on your dog 24/7. That just isn’t healthy for dogs. I recommend taking it off for a few hours a day because you do need to charge it. Just make sure to vary the time that you take it off. If you don’t vary the time, then your dog will quickly figure out when it’s ok to bark.